
I sent 1,298 cold emails and got exactly one reply. That is a reply rate of about 0.08%, even after all these years of doing this! In this post I will show you the real emails I sent, why they failed, the short email that finally started to get replies, and a B2B email marketing template you can copy.
So B2B cold email marketing is hard. Yes, sending cold emails has gotten easier these days (that’s the good part), but at the same time it has gotten even harder to get a reply. I have been doing email marketing for more than 10 years now. I first started at my job at Dell, and once I left Dell I started on my own freelance work and sent out emails for my clients as well. Slowly, I learnt how to track open rates and how to send multiple emails, and yes, I started with mail merge to create bulk email templates for many people. I am quite certain the new generation may not have heard of mail merge!
Anyway, these days I send thousands of emails per month, and nearly everyone comes back with no replies. I really wish sometimes that people would just reply saying no thanks (most of the time there is an unsubscribe link these days, which makes even those replies very few).
One day, while going through my messages on LinkedIn, one message caught my eye. It said they would send a video, and that got me thinking: why don’t I do something like that? From then on, I wrote an email asking if I could share a video about what I would change on their website, and what do you know! That email template started to get replies. In a week, getting more than five email replies was a victory!
So what I learnt is that offering something for free, especially in the first email, helps in getting replies! Not asking for a free video call! That is a strict no! Also, these tips are for cold emails. Email newsletters are a different kind of email, since the customer has mostly come to your website or been in touch with you, and knows you better!
Want help setting up cold email campaigns that actually get replies?
If you want help with your outreach, your CRM and email campaigns you can measure, take a look at my IT services and implementation page, or get in touch and I am happy to talk it through.
Email me Know more about meCold email reply rate: 1,298 emails, one reply
These are the numbers directly from SuiteCRM: 1,298 emails sent and one reply, which is a cold email reply rate of about 0.08%. SuiteCRM is the CRM tool that I use for keeping my contacts and sending out emails to clients. I track the open rates, but the challenge is that most tools these days, even Gmail, open the email beforehand and can trigger an open. It could even be a spam filter that is placed there before the email reaches the user. I wrote about this in more detail in Apple Mail Privacy Protection: Why Your Email Open Rates Are Wrong. I will not quote an average cold email reply rate that I cannot back up, so compare your own batches against each other.
So now the only way I can tell if people are interested is mostly the click rate, and even that can sometimes be false. If you do not get any reply, then the problem is the email itself. It is just not offering anything valuable to the customer, so the potential customer does not feel that replying will get them something out of it.
How I send these emails with SuiteCRM
I send every batch of cold emails from my own SuiteCRM, which I host myself. There is no Mailchimp, no per-contact pricing, and no copying lists from one tool to another. Here is how a batch goes out.
First, I create a target list for the batch and name it with the date. Every lead I add to the CRM that day goes into that list. Then I create a campaign and attach the list to it. I use the Newsletter campaign type even for outreach, because it gives me the unsubscribe handling I need.
Each email in the sequence is its own Email Marketing record, with its own subject, body and start date. SuiteCRM does not have a “wait seven days” step, so the gap between emails comes only from those start dates. The first name and company name are filled in automatically when the email goes out, which is the modern version of mail merge!
I also keep one shared suppression list across all my campaigns, so anyone who unsubscribes is blocked from every email that follows. And I keep the emails as plain text with a simple signature, since they land in the inbox far more often than designed emails.
Talking about the pain point
Yes, this is a strategy that works, but I still feel it can be improved. The problem is that everyone now senses the pain point email. It has become a common practice, and AI especially loves using this technique. What has happened to the technique is that people have stopped opening these emails, since they know they are sales emails.
Keeping it short and sweet
Another thing I have noticed is that people do not like long messages. When I say long, I mean anything beyond 500 characters. And what can you even say within that many characters?
Offer something for free!
This is a technique used very widely in shopping malls and grocery stores, where people give you samples of food or small gifts to make you aware of the product or brand. I say the same tactic is really useful in email marketing, or even messaging. If you are a service business and you offer a free video on how you can build their business, it will get your name out there. It shows others that you know their product, that you have done your homework and know their problems too, and it also shows them who you are and what you are capable of. A free video is also a much easier cold email call to action than asking for a meeting.
Cold email examples: my good and bad emails for everyone to see

Here is an email I sent to clients that got nearly no replies. The biggest mistake, even as a marketer, was mentioning the price.
Subject: Dedicated marketing engine for [Company]?
Hi [First name],
I came across [Company] and wanted to reach out directly.
I’m a growth marketer, and I help independent companies run their entire marketing engine without the heavy agency price tag. For a flat £350/month, I handle everything directly:
* Building and optimizing your website
* Setting up and managing your CRM (completely free)
* Mapping contacts and running your email campaigns
* Launching paid and social media campaigns to drive leads
You get a senior partner managing your pipeline, with zero hand-offs to junior staff. You can see my past work and full setup details directly at reuben.findingcities.in.
Are you open to adding a hands-off growth setup to your business this month?
Below is a good cold email example, one I sent to clients that started to get replies.
Subject: video for [Company]
Hi [First name],
Would you mind if I recorded a three minute video going through [Company]'s website and what I would change to get more people finding it on Google?
No call needed, I would just send it over. You can see what I do at reuben.findingcities.in.
Feel free to copy it as a B2B cold email template and swap in your own details.
I do not send just one email. I send three, one week apart. Emails two and three use “Re:” in the subject line and quote the email before them, the way a mail client does when you reply. That makes the follow-up read like a nudge in an existing conversation and not a fresh marketing email.
Here is the second email, sent a week later:
Subject: Re: video for [Company]
Hi [First name],
Wanted to make sure this reached you. I am happy to record the video for [Company] this week, a simple yes is enough.
Examples of my work are at reuben.findingcities.in.
And here is the third email, one more week later:
Subject: Re: video for [Company]
Hi [First name],
Last one from me. If you ever want that short video on [Company]'s website, reply “video” and I will record it for you.
You can see what I do at reuben.findingcities.in.
Notice that the last email gives the reader one word to type back. That makes replying very easy.
Yes, these emails may not be perfect emails that reach a closure, but that is not the goal of a cold email. Your first email in B2B cold email marketing is never about closing the deal. It is about how you can help the client, and the client getting to know you. If they are interested, they will reply. If they are not interested, they will most probably unsubscribe, and if they do not reply, leave it. Using your email system will help you increase the chances of getting a reply back from your clients.
Want a second pair of eyes on your cold email?
If you would like help with your emails, your SuiteCRM setup or the follow-up sequence behind them, see how I can help on my IT services and implementation page, or send me a message.
Email me Know more about meThe short version
- Keep the first email short, and make it about them and not about you.
- Leave the price out of the first email.
- Offer something free, like a short video, instead of asking for a call.
- Judge a campaign by replies, since opens and clicks can be false.
FAQ
What is a good B2B cold email reply rate?
I will not quote an average I cannot back up. My own first batch was 1,298 emails and one reply, about 0.08%. The best comparison is your own batches against each other, judged by replies and not by opens.
How long should a B2B cold email be?
Short. In my experience people do not like anything beyond about 500 characters. The email that finally got replies was only three sentences.
Should I put my price in a cold email?
No. The email where I mentioned a monthly price got nearly no replies. The first email is about how you can help and about getting to know each other, not about closing the deal.
How many follow-up emails should I send?
I send three emails in total, one week apart. The second and third use “Re:” in the subject line so they read like a nudge in an existing conversation.
What is a good call to action for a cold email?
Offer something free, like a short video about their website, and do not ask for a call. In my last email I ask the reader to reply with one word, which makes replying very easy.


Pingback: Why I Took the Price Out of My First Cold Email – Reuben Noronha